Russell Stover is best known at Easter for their little one ounce eggs that come in over a dozen varieties from the classic strawberry creme to the trendy wedding cake and cookie dough. One of the other items that’s a little harder to find are Russell Stover’s version of Cadbury Creme Eggs that come in chocolate creme and caramel (review).
One of the newer varieties, or at least to me, is the Russell Stover Peanut Butter Egg. Russell Stover first introduced their little foil wrapped eggs in 2008, they came in some interesting varieties like Marshmallow & Caramel and Dark Chocolate with Chocolate Creme. I picked mine up on sale at 2 for 99 cents. The plain blue foil wrapping doesn’t say much other than the fact that it’s peanut butter in milk chocolate.
The center is a combination of peanut butter, sugar and corn syrup. So it’s more like a peanut butter frosting than just a plain old peanut butter filling.
The egg is 1.2 ounces and is molded to be completely ovoid, not one of those flat-bottomed enrobed eggs. The design on the shell is very simple, with just a few embellishments.
Oddly enough, Russell Stover uses this same mold throughout the year. They have some sports themed hollow chocolates they sell, including a football, which makes lots of sense when covered in a brown texture-look foil. The odder part of that set of chocolates though is that the same shape is used for baseballs, soccer balls and basketballs.

The filling is not a peanut butter, as I mentioned, instead, it’s more like a peanut butter caramel frosting. The texture is smooth, but not quite chewy like a caramel. If you gave me a cupcake with this as the icing, I’d be pretty happy. The milk chocolate is very sweet, but goes well with the filling. The peanut butter flavor is muted by the sugary sauce its within, but it still works.
It’s not quite my thing, but it stands as unique take on this candy genre. I actually might buy these again and would probably include them in an Easter basket for kids if I put something together this year.
Related Candies
- Russell Stover Cookie Dough Egg
- Twix Egg
- Cadbury Chocolate Creme Egg
- Russell Stover White Chocolate Peanut Butter Rabbit
- Russell Stover Eggs (2009 edition)
- Reese’s Enigma & Chocolate Covered Peanut Butter Eggs
- Russell Stover Eggs
- Peeps Mash Ups
-
Comment by
Robin on 3/11/15 at 8:17 pm #
-
Comment by
Alek on 3/15/15 at 1:04 pm #
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.Nothing can replace the place in my heart held by Reese’s white chocolate-covered peanut butter eggs available this time of year.
It would be ideal if you scraped off the filling and then used the chocolate in the cupcake base. Mix some whipped cream and fold some of that filling. YUM!
Next entry: Koppers Chocolate Marshmallow Eggs
Previous entry: YumEarth Organics Gummy Fruits